There are 5 visitors online, 682 total debates, and 3614 debate responses.


Drug Testing should be a federal law for all on Welfare


Saw this on facebook and think it is a good debate; original debate: As of July 1st Florida became the first state to require drug testing for all welfare recipients . People are crying saying it's unconstitutional. How so? It's OK to test people who work for their money, but not for those that don't? Repost if you think all states should have this law!



    


This debate is over...

The Winner is:

Pro with ( 22 ) responses






PRO (7)


I had to be drug tested to become employed by my employer; why shouldn't someone who is taking money off of tax paying citizens be held to the same standard. Totally agree with this.

I pay for them

Posted by I pay for them

282 days ago



Since 1991 I have had to pass a drug screen to get hired at every job I have been at. Have also had to make myself available at any time for random drug screens. I consider this a reasonable condition of employment since the company is investing a lot of money and time in me as a fulltime employee. To those who say it infringes on people's rights I say what rights would that be. If they can't pass a drug screen it is because they are either doing one of 2 things. Using drugs that have been declared illegal by law, or misusing prescription drugs they have obtained illegally. How can a person on welfare ever get a job if they can't pass a drug screen as a condition of employment. At least this way they would be clean when they interviewed. At some point we need to quit worrying so much about infringing on individual rights and start demanding individual responsibility as a condition of living in this great American society.

Dr. Oz

Posted by Dr. Oz

281 days ago



I do know that if I'm on welfare and I have to choose between food or crack, I'm going with food any day of the week. That's just me, though.

Posted by JohnBrown

281 days ago



Agree 100%. Many people on Welfare take advantage of labor-free income and spend it on unnecessary things. Drug testing must be done to people on Welfare.

Posted by ScarfaceZel

281 days ago



I agree 110% with drug testing. Most of these people would fail and wouldn't be able to use my hard earned tax dollars for drugs and booze.

Posted by Mr X

279 days ago



I agree. Individuals should be required to get drug tested for Welfare.

Posted by JR

279 days ago



Welfare is a free ride for men to shirt having to go to work. They have a lot of babies and receive benefits with no desire to do better. Sometimes they will work under the table for something they want personally and let the state cover there burden of there support. I know unemployment is up but a lot of the people on walfare are gang bangers who deal drugs and driver better cars than I do. They go to jail. We pay walfare for the babies. Then we pay for them in be in jail so drug testing might be less expensive than Jail time and welfare. When does this insanity end and where is the insentive to do better begin. They want respect,but It isn't earned by not being a productive member of society.

diggs

Posted by diggs

224 days ago



AGAINST (3)


Drug tests for those collecting social security & Medicare as well?

Peaches66

Posted by Peaches66

281 days ago



I strongly support the idea of welfare recipients having to pass drug tests.. However, making it a federal law would be extremely unconstitutional as the fed gov't has no right to be making such decisions.. Power belongs to the individual states on this matter.

JaiminS

Posted by JaiminS

278 days ago



I agree. Drug testing should be required for these individuals.

So Right

Posted by So Right

267 days ago





Login to WeDebate.it


WeDebate.it Twitter Page WeDebate.it Facebook Page WeDebate.it YouTube Videos
Registration is optional at WeDebate.it

Political Debates




Links Site Links  
  Start New Debate About Us In The News
  Most Debated Topics Contact Us Media Info
  Random Debate Blog Links
  Signup / Register iPhone App

© Copyright 2010-2011 WeDebate.it LLC - All Rights Reserved - Designed by: John Cushma